Tax and Accounting Services

Thinking About Switching Accountants?

Here’s What to Consider

Home » Thinking About Switching Accountants? Here’s What to Consider

Tax Preparation Made Easier

Changing accountants can feel like a big decision—especially if you’ve worked with the same tax professional for years.

But as your finances or business change, the level of service you need may change too. You may have difficulty getting answers, want a clearer understanding of your tax situation, need help keeping your accounting current, or be looking for more proactive guidance throughout the year.

That doesn’t necessarily mean your current accountant is doing something wrong. It may simply mean the relationship is no longer the right fit for what you need.

If you’re thinking about switching accountants, here are some things to consider before making the change.

Signs It May Be Time to Switch Accountants

There isn’t one single reason people decide to change accountants. Often, it’s a combination of issues that develops over time.

You may want to consider whether a different accountant would be a better fit if:

You regularly have difficulty getting answers to important questions.
You receive your tax return but don’t understand the results or why you owe what you owe.
Your business or financial situation has become more complex.
You need accounting or bookkeeping support in addition to tax preparation.
You want to discuss tax decisions before the year is over—not only when it’s time to prepare the return.
You aren’t sure what services you’re receiving or what you’re paying for.
Your current accountant no longer provides the level of service or guidance you need.

One frustrating experience doesn’t necessarily mean you need a new accountant. But if the same problems happen repeatedly, it may be worth exploring your options.

Communication Matters—But So Do Expectations

One of the most common reasons new clients tell us they are changing accountants is that they had difficulty communicating with their previous tax professional.

Good communication matters. You should know how to contact your accountant, how questions are handled, and what to expect during the tax preparation process.

At the same time, reasonable expectations matter too.

Tax professionals can be especially busy around filing deadlines, and every question may not receive an immediate response. A complicated tax question may also require research before an accountant can give you a reliable answer.

The important question isn’t necessarily, “Does my accountant respond immediately?”

A better question is:

“Do I understand how communication works, and am I getting the information and guidance I reasonably need?”

A good professional relationship should provide clarity about both.

Do You Need a Tax Preparer—or More Than Tax Preparation?

Sometimes dissatisfaction with an accountant comes from a mismatch between the service a client is receiving and the service they actually need.

Tax preparation primarily looks backward. Your tax professional uses information about what already happened to prepare and file your tax returns accurately.

For many taxpayers, that may be exactly what they need.

But a business owner or someone with a more complex tax situation may want more.

Tax planning and advisory services are forward-looking. They can include tax projections, evaluating planning opportunities, discussing the tax impact of business decisions, and making adjustments while there is still time to act.

If your concern is that you only learn how much you owe when your return is prepared, simply changing tax preparers may not solve the underlying problem. You may actually be looking for a different level of service.

Similarly, if your business books are months behind or you don’t have reliable financial information, the first issue may be your accounting rather than your tax return.

Understanding what you need makes it much easier to evaluate whether a new accountant is a better fit.

What Should You Look for in a New Accountant?

If you’ve decided to explore other options, don’t evaluate a new accountant based on one factor alone.

Qualifications and experience

Find out who will actually prepare your work and what qualifications they have.

Depending on your needs, you may also want to know whether the firm regularly works with businesses, investments, rental properties, multi-state filings, or other issues relevant to your situation.

Communication

Ask how the firm communicates with clients.

How do you submit questions? Who answers them? What should you expect during tax season? Is communication limited to tax preparation, or are year-round services available if you need them?

You don’t need a promise of instant responses. You need a process that works for you.

Services

Think beyond what you need today.

An individual with a straightforward tax return may only need annual tax preparation. A growing business may eventually need bookkeeping, payroll coordination, tax projections, entity planning, or ongoing advisory services.

A firm that offers multiple levels of service can make it easier to adjust as your needs change.

Process and technology

Ask how documents are collected and how sensitive information is protected.

A secure client portal can make it easier to exchange tax documents without relying on ordinary email attachments.

For virtual services, also consider how consultations are handled and whether the process is clear from the beginning.

Pricing

You should understand how the firm determines its fees and which services are included.

The lowest price doesn’t necessarily represent the best value, but you also shouldn’t have to enter a professional relationship without understanding how you’ll be charged.

At DuPage Tax Solutions, we publish starting prices for our primary services so prospective clients can evaluate whether our services are likely to fit their needs before scheduling a consultation.

Is It Difficult to Switch Accountants?

Usually, switching accountants is more straightforward than people expect.

You generally aren’t required to continue using the accountant who prepared your previous return, and you don’t need to wait until a new tax year simply because you have worked with the same firm in the past.

Your new accountant will need enough information to understand your tax history and prepare the current work accurately.

That commonly includes copies of prior-year tax returns and current-year tax documents. Business clients may also need to provide accounting records and other financial information.

Depending on your situation, you may need to request certain records from your previous accountant. Starting the transition early gives you more time to gather anything that may be missing.

When Is the Best Time to Switch Accountants?

There is no single date when you have to change accountants.

However, earlier is usually easier.

If you know you want to work with someone new for the upcoming filing season, making the change before the busiest part of tax season gives the new accountant more time to review your situation and identify anything they need.

For businesses, changing earlier can be particularly helpful if accounting records need to be reviewed or brought up to date before the return can be prepared.

What if you already filed an extension?

Filing an extension does not mean you have to use the same tax preparer who filed it.

If your return has not yet been filed, you can generally choose a different tax professional to prepare it.

An extension gives you additional time to file the return, but it’s still better not to wait until the extended deadline is approaching before beginning the transition.

What Information Will Your New Accountant Need?

Exactly what your new accountant needs will depend on your tax situation, but you may be asked for items such as:

Prior-year federal and state tax returns
Current-year tax forms and income documents
Estimated tax payment information
IRS or state tax notices
Business accounting records
Payroll information
Details about major purchases or asset sales
Information about significant changes during the year

If you’re preparing to file and aren’t sure what to gather, see our guide Getting Ready to File? Here’s How to Prepare for Your Tax Return for a more detailed explanation of the tax preparation process and the information you may need.

Questions to Ask Before Switching Accountants

A consultation with a prospective accountant isn’t only an opportunity for the accountant to determine whether they can help you. It’s also your opportunity to determine whether the firm is right for you.

Consider asking:

Who will prepare and review my tax return?
How does your firm communicate with clients?
How do I securely submit documents?
What services are included in the quoted fee?
How does your pricing work?
Do you provide year-round tax planning if I need it?
Do you offer bookkeeping or accounting services?
Do you have experience with situations similar to mine?
What should I expect after I become a client?

The answers should help you compare firms based on the relationship and services you actually need—not simply the price of preparing a return.

A Different Accountant Should Also Mean the Right Accountant

If your current accounting relationship isn’t meeting your needs, exploring other options doesn’t mean you have to make an immediate change.

First, identify what isn’t working.

Do you need better communication? More explanation? More reliable bookkeeping? A tax professional with experience relevant to your situation? Or are you actually looking for proactive tax planning throughout the year?

Once you know what you need, you can make a much more informed decision about whether switching accountants makes sense—and what you should look for in the next one.

At DuPage Tax Solutions, licensed professionals provide tax preparation, accounting, bookkeeping, and advisory services to individuals and businesses nationwide. Our services are designed around clear processes, secure document exchange, transparent pricing, and the ability to add year-round support when your situation calls for it.

Related Tax Resources

Start 2027 With Clean, Current Books: A Year-End Bookkeeping Checklist

Year-End Bookkeeping Checklist for Business Owners

Use this year-end bookkeeping checklist to review your accounts, transactions, payroll, and financial statements so you can start 2027 with clean, current books you can rely on.

Year-End Financial Review for Business Owners

Learn what business owners should review before year-end to understand where their business stands, prepare for tax planning, and address financial issues while there is still time.

Why Accurate Bookkeeping Matters for Year-End Tax Planning

Year-end tax planning starts with reliable numbers. Learn how accurate bookkeeping supports tax projections and helps business owners evaluate potential tax-planning opportunities before year-end.

Looking for a Different Accounting Experience?

If you’re considering a change, tell us what you’re looking for and see whether DuPage Tax Solutions is the right fit for your tax and accounting needs.

Contact Info

Ph. (630) 909 9700
Email: DPTax@DP-Tax.com

Mail address:
1552 Illinois Rte 59 #1037
Naperville, IL 60564

Business Hours

Mon: 11 am – 7 pm
Tue: 11 am – 7 pm
Wed: 11 am – 7 pm
Thu: 11 am – 7 pm
Fri: 11 am – 7 pm
Sat: 12 pm – 5 pm
Sun: CLOSED